The Treasury has released the ASIC review on mortgage broker remuneration, together with two info-graphics on the industry. The findings will shape the future of the mortgage industry, and are now open for consultation.
There are two primary ways in which these conflicts may become evident. Firstly, a broker could recommend a loan that is larger than the consumer needs or can afford to maximise their commission payment. This may also involve recommending a particular product or strategy to maximise the amount that the consumer can borrow (e.g. through the choice of an interest-only loan). In this report, we have referred to this as a ‘product strategy conflict’. Alternatively, a broker could be incentivised to recommend a loan from a particular lender because the broker will receive a higher commission, even though that loan may not be the best loan for the consumer. We refer to this as a ‘lender choice conflict’.
(a) changing the standard commission model to reduce the risk of poor consumer outcomes;(b) moving away from bonus commissions and bonus payments, which increase the risk of poor consumer outcomes;(c) moving away from soft dollar benefits, which increase the risk of poor consumer outcomes and can undermine competition;(d) clearer disclosure of ownership structures within the home loan market to improve competition;(e) establishing a new public reporting regime of consumer outcomes and competition in the home loan market; and(f) improving the oversight of brokers by lenders and aggregators.
Here is the Treasury release.
As part of the Government’s response to the Financial System Inquiry (FSI), Improving Australia’s Financial System 2015, the Government requested ASIC undertake an industry-wide review of mortgage broker remuneration.
The Review found that the current mortgage broker remuneration and ownership structures create conflicts of interest that may contribute to poor consumer outcomes.
The Review outlines a number of proposals for industry aimed at improving consumer outcomes, including:
- improving the standard commission model for mortgage brokers;
- moving away from bonus commissions and soft-dollar benefits;
- increasing the disclosure of mortgage broker ownership structures; and
- improving the oversight of mortgage brokers by lenders and aggregators.
The proposals outlined in this paper are intended to elicit specific and focused feedback, and should not be viewed as a statement of the Government’s final policy position.
The Government invites all interested parties to make a submission on the proposals outlined in this paper. Closing date for submissions: Friday, 30 June 2017