Mortgage Stress Update November 2022

In our final update of the year, we incorporate the latest from our surveys as we assess the impact higher interest rates are having on households across the country, based on our rolling 52,000 omnibus survey.

And the news is not good, in that both mortgage stress and rental stress – defined in terms of cash-flow in and out, continues to grow, following the eighth rate hike from the RBA, which was promptly passed on to households by way of higher mortgage rates, (though not reflected to the same extent in higher deposit account rates I might add). There was also a continued rise in average rents, thanks to intense competition, lower supply and leveraged investors. All this set against an average inflation rate expected to hit eight per cent soon.

There are many different definitions out there (from 30% of income, or taxable income; through to underwriting metrics) but we define stress in CASH FLOW terms. If households have more outgoings (excluding one off discretionary items) than income, we define them as stressed. If they have a mortgage, they are in mortgage stress; if renting then rental stress.

Investors with cash flow pressures are identified as stressed investors. We also aggregate the data to estimate total financial stress.  Each expressed as a % of households, and count. The latter is the best measure in our view.

This month, more than 1.75 million households with an owner-occupied mortgage, or 45.8% of borrowers register as stressed, while more than 1.88 million renting households, or 60.85% are stressed. And the household debt to income remains very high, as reported by the RBA.

Analysis By State

In this slide, we highlight in yellow where the proportion of households in stress rose compared with last month, blue means a fall, and no highlight means no change. Tasmania and South Australia are now vying for top spot, both with more than half of household in a negative cash flow situation. WA and Victoria follow on, then NSW and the other states.

Rental stress is most significant in NSW, ACT and QLD. Investor stress is highest in NSW, because many investors are over-geared and experiencing significant rate hikes. Overall financial stress (an aggregated measure reveals that the state with the highest proportion of household in financial stress is the ACT.

Analysis By Cohort

We analyse our data by different household segments or cohorts, as this provides an important lens to understand what is playing out across the country.

Mortgage stress is highest among Young Growing Families (which include many First Time Buyers) at 84.69%. We see also large counts of those on the Urban Fringe, as well as some more affluent households exposed. Rental stress is highest among first generation migrants at 69.49%. Investor stress is highest among Young Affluent households and overall financial stress is highest among Young Growing Families.

Whilst we continue to see stress building in the high growth suburbs, where many purchasers entered the market when mortgage rates were around 2%, we continue to see pockets of stress across different areas, including some which would generally be regarded as more affluent. Many households in these regions have large mortgages.

It is worth reflecting on the fact that about one quarter of mortgage holders have so far been insulated from mortgage rate rises because they are on fix term loans. However, many of these are due to reset next year, as the RBA showed in a recent report.

The expectation is that rates will still be high through 2023, and that mortgage delinquencies will rise, at the same time a property prices continue to slide. This is a perfect storm.

Post Code Analysis

We list the top post codes in each category, based on the COUNT of households.

Conclusions

We do not expect things to ease ahead, as interest rate rises continue to work though, and rental costs rise. Inflation is running hotter than expected, and the RBA still expects a peak around 8% but also staying high through 2023. As a result, households need to get to grips with their cash flow and prioritise important payments, such as mortgage and rental payments, over other perhaps less critical payments.

Households under mortgage pressure would do well to talk to their bank who do run hardship schemes designed to assist in times of crisis.

We also recommend the Government Debt Help Line on 1800 007 007 for people seeking unbiased free advice.

Finally, real wages growth remains below inflation, so households must consider the scenario where true incomes continue to shrink in real terms. As a result, stress levels will remain high for some time yet.

A Real Deep Perspective On Crypto…

I caught up with the CEO of BTC Markets to discuss the broader perspectives on Crypto in the light of FTX.

https://www.btcmarkets.net/about-us

Perhaps we should be careful not to put the baby out with the bathwater!

“Our vision is to build the digital financial infrastructure for the future. We are moving forward with that overarching and audacious strategy and can clearly see how this will roll out.” Caroline Bowler CEO, BTC Markets

Go to the Walk The World Universe at https://walktheworld.com.au/

Who Is The Bigger Fool?

The latest edition of our finance and property news digest with a distinctively Australian flavour. We look at the action on the markets, the $80 trillion-dollar black hole in the financial system, and why Oil is so weak. All ahead of the FED next week who are expected to push rates higher – as recession risks grow.

CONTENTS

0:00 Start
0:15 Introduction
1:35 Stronger PPI
5:10 US Markets
6:18 Oil and Contango
9:09 Gold
9:30 Europe And Credit Suisse
13:05 Asia
14:39 Australia
18:40 Short Sellers Exit
20:20 Crypto
21: 55 $80 Tr Black Hole
27:00 Summary And Close

Go to the Walk The World Universe at https://walktheworld.com.au/

Spend, Spend, Spend, In 2023 With Tarric Brooker

My latest Friday afternoon chat with Journalist Tarric Brooker, as we walk through the key charts as we come to the end of 2022. So, what might 2023 look like?

Go to the Walk The World Universe at https://walktheworld.com.au/

Links to Tarric’s charts and recent articles:

https://avidcom.substack.com/p/charts-that-matter-9th-december?sd=pf

https://avidcom.substack.com/p/how-long-can-australians-keep-spending

Are There Signs Of Bank Mortgage Portfolio Stress Yet?

Given we now have mortgage rates 3% higher than at the start of the year – analysts are asking whether there are yet signs of mortgage portfolio risks in the banking system.

We certainly know that households cash flows are under pressure, from our own mortgage stress analysis, and Roy Morgan’s research on consumer confidence and their own mortgage stress analysis.

And we know that APRA’s 3% “Buffer” is being breached now, and it is even worse when they had set a 2% buffer earlier on.

But all that said, there is a lag between rate rises and delinquency – of months, if not years, so I would not be expecting much movement yet – that comes later. This also aligns with recent incoming data too.

For example, according to the latest Quarterly Statistics from APRA, the banks wrote fewer high loan-to-value ratio mortgages and decreased high debt-to-income lending over the September quarter, which the prudential regulator has welcomed.

They welcomed the fact that the banks have been “improving” the risk characteristics of their new residential mortgage lending, after finding that both high debt-to-income (DTI) and high LVR lending had reduced over the September quarter and suggested that the figures were largely promising given the strength of the banks’ profitability and liquidity positions as well as the reduction in “riskier” lending.

Today’s post is brought to you by Ribbon Property Consultants.

Now Where Will Rates Go, And What Does It All Mean?

With the latest rises in rates of 3% flowing through to the markets, we look at the impact, now and ahead with Steve Mickenbecker from Canstar.

CONTENTS
0:00 Start
0:53 Housing Shortages and Stress
11:40 Interest Rates Moves
20:00 Fixed Rate Cliff Ahead
25:30 Credit Card Issuing Up
34:00 Refinancing Risks
40:30 Deposits
49:00 Financial Homework For The Holidays

Steve Mickenbecker is in Canstar’s Group Executive Team, bringing more than 30 years of experience in the Australian financial services industry. As a financial commentator for Canstar, Steve enjoys sharing his expertise across topics such as home loans, superannuation, insurance, mortgages, banking, credit cards, investment, budgeting, money management and more.

https://www.canstar.com.au/team-members/steve-mickenbecker/

Go to the Walk The World Universe at https://walktheworld.com.au/

The Eighth Rate Rise In A Row: What Next?

I caught up with Peter Marshall from Mozo to discuss the latest following the RBA 25 basis points rise yesterday. What is going to happen ahead, and how should households be planning to manage under the new higher-rate environment? And of course, after the eighth, comes the ninth…. etc….

Peter Marshall has been working in the Australian banking and finance industry for over 20 years and oversees Mozo’s extensive product database. He is regularly sought out for his expert commentary and analysis on banking and interest rates trends by print, radio and TV media.

https://mozo.com.au/

Go to the Walk The World Universe at https://walktheworld.com.au/

FINAL REMINDER: DFA Live 8pm Sydney – Household Finances Stress Scenario Update

Join me for a live discussion about the latest from our models. We will have the post code engine online.

You can ask a question live!

Go to the Walk The World Universe at https://walktheworld.com.au/

How To Save At Least Six Communities From Bankers’ Bastardry!

An important call to arms with Robbie Barwick from the Australian Citizens Party, aimed at saving SIX bank branches which are ear-marked for closure in the next few days, leaving more communities in the lurch, without property banking services in the community.

In the next fortnight, the big banks which gorge themselves on massive profits from taxpayer support will shut down branches in 10 regional towns around Australia.

Six of those towns will lose their last bank, which will be a massive blow to the local economy and community. They are:

NSW
• Bombala NAB: closing 8 December
QLD
• Dysart NAB: closing 15 December
WA
• Tom Price Westpac: closing 16 December
• Wongan Hills Westpac: closing 16 December
SA
• Mannum BankSA (Westpac): closing 16 December
• Yankalilla BankSA (Westpac): closing 9 December

Please call the Treasurer, and Members relevant to the state in which the branches are located and demand that the Government intervenes to stop this community damage from occurring.

https://citizensparty.org.au/dec-branch-closures-contact

Contact details:
Treasurer Jim Chalmers: 02 6277 7340 (Parliament) 07 3299 5910 (Electorate)
Eden-Monaro MP Kirsty McBain: 02 6284 2442 (Bombala NAB branch)
Capricornia MP Michelle Landry: 07 4922 6604 (Dysart NAB)
Durack MP Melissa Price: 08 9964 2195 (Geraldton) 08 9041 1749 (Merredin) (Tom Price and Wongan Hills Westpacs)
Barker MP Tony Pasin: 08 8531 2466 (Mannum BankSA)
Mayo MP Rebekha Sharkie: 08 8398 5566 (Yankalilla BankSA)
Gilmore MP Fiona Phillips: 02 4423 1782 (Vincentia Westpac)
O’Connor MP Rick Wilson: 08 9842 2777 (Collie and Bridgetown Westpacs)
Wright MP Scott Bucholz: 07 5541 0150 (Laidley NAB)

Go to the Walk The World Universe at https://walktheworld.com.au/

More Operation Antispruik In The Illawarra!

Another outing thanks to Cookie’s research on property price falls on the portals, plus my own analysis based on DFA stress, this time looking at the falls across the Illawarra.

Whilst not statistically significant necessarily, it does reinforce the down trends. Thanks again to Cookie.

Go to the Walk The World Universe at https://walktheworld.com.au/