Fitch Ratings Expects Subdued Global Home Price Growth Despite Low Rates

Fitch Ratings forecasts subdued home price growth around the globe over the next couple of years due to a combination of stretched affordability, more challenging macro-economic conditions and macro-prudential measures restricting mortgage eligibility. This is despite falling or very low mortgage rates, insufficient supply in major cities and stable or improved employment levels in most countries.

Political risks and their impact on economic growth and policy decisions are also affecting our housing outlooks with lingering US-China trade uncertainty, despite the recent easing in tensions, and China’s de-risking drive, Brexit, and developments around mortgage and housing policy beginning to take a toll.

The US-China trade dispute and China’s de-risking drive are weighing on global and national growth prospects, not only for the US and China, but also for their closest trading partners (such as Australia and Canada) and areas like the EU that are exposed to global trade.

“Weaker economic growth is a key driver of more modest home price growth forecasts. UK home price growth will continue to be affected by lingering trade ‘cliff edge’ risks until the new UK-EU relationship is negotiated. Although the newly elected Conservative government is expected to pursue a formal exit next month, there is more uncertainty about its ability to negotiate a UK-EU Free Trade Agreement by the end of 2020,” said Suzanne Albers, Senior Director of Structured Finance at Fitch.

In some countries, there is also uncertainty around mortgage and housing policy. The US and Canada are reducing the government’s role in mortgage funding while in Mexico and Colombia new national housing plans may increase government participation.

Of the 24 countries covered in the report we expect a nominal price fall only in Italy and Japan, due to Italy’s sluggish economy and Japan’s post-Olympics hangover and a decline in real prices in Brazil, Canada, China and the UK. We also forecast accelerating growth in Australia and Sweden, where prices are recovering from recent falls, as well as in New Zealand and Colombia.

We forecast low arrears levels for most countries covered in the report in light of flat or falling policy rates. However, we also have concerns about long-term low rates. Under a market stress, the limited scope for further policy rate cuts would mean that home prices would not benefit from substantial rate cuts as per recent downturns.

In this low interest-rate environment, lenders are also struggling to originate the volumes needed to defend profits, which has resulted in higher loan-to-values (LTVs) and longer maturities being offered in several European countries. Household debt levels remain the highest in Australia, Canada, Denmark, the Netherlands and Norway, making their economies more exposed to shocks and borrowers more vulnerable to downturns.

Longer-term, the push towards ESG investments may change housing investment and mortgage funding.

“Fitch expects climate change will permanently affect housing demand in areas that are already or could become more exposed to natural disasters, if they fail to attract new buyers or affordable insurance. Population redistribution to cities will continue, which will support cities’ higher price dynamism, but conversely ageing populations and developments in remote working and self-driving vehicles are likely to also drive regional prices,” adds Albers.

CoreLogic National Index Rose 4.0% Over December Quarter

CoreLogic released their updated data to end December 2019 today.

They confirm a 1.1% rise in national dwelling values over the month, and a 4.0% increase over the quarter to finish out 2019 on a positive note.

This result represents the fastest rate of national dwelling value growth over any three month period since November 2009. Darwin was the only region among the capital cities and ‘rest-of-state’ areas to record a fall in values over the month, with a -0.5% decline.

CoreLogic head of research Tim Lawless said, “Although the monthly capital gains trend remains fast-paced, the 1.1% rise in December was softer relative to the 1.7% gain in November and the 1.2% rise in October. This would suggest that the pace of capital gains may have been dampened by higher advertised stock levels or worsening affordability pressures through early summer.”  

Despite a strong rebound over the second half of 2019, property values across most regions of Australia are still below their previous record highs. Nationally, the CoreLogic index recorded a peak in October 2017; dwelling values remained 3.1% below their record high at the end of 2019. If the current quarterly rate of growth persists into 2020, the national housing market will record a nominal recovery in March as dwelling values push higher to new record highs.

Tim Lawless said, “A nominal recovery in housing values implies home owners are becoming wealthier, which may also help to support household spending. However, the flipside is that housing affordability is set to deteriorate even further as dwelling values outpace growth in household incomes, signaling a set-back for those saving for a deposit.”

2019 – A Year In Review

We highlight some of the main issues this year, and also our most popular posts of the year. Wishing all our followers a happy new year!

Our top posts for this year:

The Real Issues Behind The Cash Ban

Lynette Zang And The “Great Reset”

The Cash Ban Breakthrough – The Game’s Afoot!

Harry Dent LIVE: How To Survive And Thrive From the Volatile Times Ahead

Harry Dent Says The Bubble Still Has To Burst!

The “Good News” On Property Prices?

A Conversation With Steve Keen: Part One – The Debt Problem

A Conversation With Steve Keen: Part 3 – Ecology and Energy; The New Horizon

Four Corners 21 Aug 2017 – Betting On The House

The Reality Of Bank Deposit Bail-In

How Low Can Deutsche Bank Go?

The Real Problem With Low Interest Rates

Crisis – What Crisis? The Latest On Home Prices ….

Australia’s Debt Bubble Is Falling Apart!

Higher Still – The Property Imperative Weekly 21st Dec 2019

The latest edition of our weekly finance and property news digest with a distinctively Australian flavour.

Contents:

  • 00:20 Introduction
  • 00:55 US Markets and Data
  • 03:40 Trade Deals
  • 05:10 Bitcoin Risks
  • 06:30 Japan
  • 07:40 China
  • 07:50 UK
  • 09:40 Sweden’s Negative Rate Reversal
  • 12:00 The Global Waves of Debt Report
  • 13:30 Australia
  • 13:30 MYEFO
  • 15:25 Unemployment and Migration
  • 16:00 Loan Flows
  • 16:35 Household Ratios
  • 17:40 Home Prices
  • 19:10 Australian Markets

DFA Live Show From 17th December 2019

In this trimmed high quality recording of our live event, we discuss the latest financial and property data, examine our latest scenarios, and discuss the trends ahead. We also answer a range of questions posed by our viewers live. The unedited original stream with live chat, is available to view (starting at 0:30) below:

Is It Time To Move Beyond Exit Polls And Tweets? – The Property Imperative Weekly 14 December 2019

The latest edition of our weekly finance and property news digest with a distinctively Australian flavour. Contents:

  1. 00:25 Introduction
  2. 00:45 Trade Deals
  3. 03:00 Impeachment
  4. 03:50 US Markets
  5. 06:20 UK Election and Brexit
  6. 08:30 ECB and Euro
  7. 09:20 Deutsche Bank
  1. 10:30 Australian Section:
  2. 10:30 ASIC Responsible Lending
  3. 12:45 BIS and Household Debt
  4. 13:00 APRA On Risks
  5. 13:30 Westpac
  6. 14:40 Citi and Deutsche Bank Action on Cartel
  7. 16:40 Home Prices and Auctions
  8. 18:15 Economics and recession fears
  9. 19:45 IMF Warns
  10. 21:00 Bank profit warnings
  11. 23:20 Markets

December Live DFA: https://youtu.be/N6QKe7IGGvc

Hopes And Fears – The Property Imperative Weekly 30th Nov 2019

The latest edition of our weekly finance and property news digest with a distinctively Australian flavour.

Contents

00:20 Introduction
00:55 US Markets
01:30 Trade Talks
05:15 Japan
05:55 Eurozone
06:20 Germany
07:10 UK
08:25 China

10:40 Australian Section
10:40 Westpac
13:30 Westpac NZ
14:30 Home Sales (HIA)
15:40 Net Government Debt
18:25 RBA on QE and Wages
19:00 Property prices and auctions
20:50 Markets

The One Australian Economic Question that Matters

Damien Klassen from Nucleus Wealth penned this recently. It is an excellent summary of the critical issue in play – Can rising house prices drive the rest of the economy on their own without a construction boom? Note the disclaimer below.

I’ve written a few times recently about the imbalances in the Australian economy and how messed up the Australian housing cycle is. It looks as if the Australian economy is hanging on to positive growth based on one factor. Without that factor, there is significant economic downside. The one economic question that matters:

Can rising house prices drive the rest of the economy on their own without a construction boom?

There are three main areas to indicate if this is the case. Two have come out with more negative data since I last posted. One is a glass half empty: better current conditions, worse future conditions.

Upside Case

Can rising house prices drive the rest of the economy on their own without a construction boom?

For the optimists, the answer is a resounding yes. House prices have not only stopped falling but have risen over the last few months. Buyer queues are out the door for limited supply which will inevitably mean rising house prices. And Morrison’s 95% lending for first home buyers hasn’t even begun yet. Investors will follow first home buyers, which will lead prices higher and then upgraders will start buying again. Rising property prices will mean consumers will start spending once more, construction will recommence, and a new Australian economic growth cycle will begin.

It would appear that the Federal Government has this belief.

Downside Case

Can rising house prices drive the rest of the economy on their own without a construction boom?

The poorer arguments mounted by pessimists tend to have a moral angle: house prices are too high for children to afford, they will have to come down to a level that an ordinary person on a regular salary can afford. If that occurs, house prices will fall 30-40%. While these arguments are compelling from a social justice perspective, or on a long term basis, the same arguments have been valid for 15 years. Timing is important:

Mortgage Prices to Income

Other weak arguments base the downturn on extrapolating no intervention from governments. We know the current government is hell-bent on intervening in the housing market.

The better argument is that even if construction approvals rebound, employment would fall for at least another year as the construction decisions made over the past two years affect the number of people employed. And construction approvals are not rebounding.

Rising unemployment in Perth led to a 10% house price fall in the 2012-2017 period while Sydney/Melbourne house prices boomed. What is to stop the same fate for Australia as a whole?

Perth Housing Crash vs Sydney/Melbourne Boom

Per capita income has gone nowhere for 7 years, so it is hard to see any rescue coming from that front:

Five years of falling Australian per capita income

If rising unemployment does mean house prices fall further, then there are a range of probable adverse effects. There are some seriously negative economic effects if the effects snowball. And we won’t even get started about the impact on a fragile Australian housing market if an international shock (Brexit, Trade wars, Hong Kong unrest, corporate debt accidents, European recession) hits.

It doesn’t need to be one or the other

You don’t need to buy into the entire negative story to be cautious. If employment holds up, then the positive story has a chance (assuming benign international conditions). But, if unemployment rises, then Australia won’t need a global shock to see house prices resume a downward path.

When presented with an asset class that has limited upside in positive scenarios and significant downside in adverse scenarios, I usually opt to avoid the asset class and look for returns elsewhere.

 Update 1: Australian Credit growth:

The Royal Commission into banking reversed the credit boom and was enough to see house prices down around 10%. This came even while most other factors affecting house prices were still positive. 

Will the Morrison government manage to get the already over-levered Australian households to take on even more debt? If I am too bearish, particularly in the short term, this is where you will see the effects. So far there are none:

Australian Credit Growth at 50 year lows
Credit growth could fall a lot further without it being unusual

On the regulatory front, the Westpac v ASIC responsible lending court case win for Westpac has the potential to lead to easy lending conditions. ASIC is taking the case to the Federal court, so we are in limbo for some time.

Update 2: Unemployment

There is not enough space here to go into the detailed links between house prices and unemployment. Indicatively, during the 2012 to 2017 housing boom years, the Perth market faced mostly the same factors as Sydney/Melbourne except for (a) slightly weaker population growth and (b) rising unemployment. And Perth property prices fell more than 10% while the rest of Australia boomed.

We are expecting considerable job losses in the construction sector.

Having said that, construction jobs have been resilient so far. Forward indicators (job ads and approvals) continue to point to sizeable job losses.

Construction job ads

Source: ABS, Seek, UBS

Add to this scenario, job losses from state government austerity as budgets have been struck by falling transaction numbers in the housing market:

Housing turnover rate

Finally, any global shock (trade wars, recessions, debt crises) is likely to be transmitted to the housing market through higher unemployment.

Update 3: Foreign Buyers

Foreign demand was substantial for both the boom and the bust:

Will foreign buyers return to the Australian housing market?

China cracking down on its capital account and deteriorating relations between Australia and China suggests foreign investment will remain low.

The question is whether Hong Kong unrest translates to increased demand for Australian property.

The Answer

So, the answer to the one question

Can rising house prices drive the rest of the economy on their own without a construction boom?

will be found in whether increases in unemployment remain contained.

I’m skeptical. But if I’m wrong, the charts above will be where we will see the signs.

Recent data suggest my skepticism is warranted.

Disclaimer

This blog contains general information and does not take into account your personal objectives, financial situation or needs. Past performance is not an indication of future performance. Damien Klassen is an authorised representative of Nucleus Wealth Management, a Corporate Authorised Representative of Nucleus Advice Pty Ltd – AFSL 515796.