Welcome to the Property Imperative weekly to 30th June 2018, our digest of the latest finance and property news with a distinctively Australian flavour.
Watch the video, listen to the podcast or read the transcript.
On the global stage, U.S. stocks were met with heavy selling pressure this week as the trade war hotted up. While earlier in the week, Donald Trump decided against imposing measures to restrict Chinese investment in U.S. based technology, the market is still reacting to the initial U.S. and Chinese tariffs which are coming into effect next week. In the world of bricks and click, Amazon was back in the headlines after the e-commerce giant announced its entry into the pharmacy sector with the purchase of Pillpoint. This triggering widespread panic, sending shares of brick-and-mortar drug stores sharply lower. Nike, meanwhile, showed improved results after revealing its first positive North America sales number in over a year. The S&P 500 closed 0.08% higher to close 2,718.37.
Boomberg says a leaked report from a Chinese government-backed think tank has warned of a potential “financial panic” in the world’s second-largest economy, a sign that some members of the nation’s policy elite are growing concerned as market turbulence and trade tensions increase. Bond defaults, liquidity shortages and the recent plunge in financial markets pose particular dangers at a time of rising US interest rates and a trade spat with Washington, according to a study by the National Institution for Finance & Development The think tank warned that leveraged purchases of shares have reached levels last seen in 2015 – when a market crash erased $US5 trillion of value. “We think China is currently very likely to see a financial panic,” NIFD said in the study, which appeared briefly on the internet on Monday, before being removed. “Preventing its occurrence and spread should be the top priority for our financial and macroeconomic regulators over the next few years.” The Australian dollar fell against the Chinese yuan from March to early May.
The China effect is on top of damming criticism of Central Bank’s policy by the Bank For International Settlements, which we discussed in our post “Red Alert From The Bankers’ Banker”. They say, economies are trapped in a series of boom-bust boom-bust cycles which are driving neutral interest rates ever lower and driving debt higher. The bigger the debt the worse the potential impact will be should rates rise (as they are thanks to the FED). Yet in each cycle “natural” interest rates are driven lower. Implicitly the current settings are wrong. This was in the Bank for International Settlements latest annual report. They also discussed how banks are fudging their ratios using Repo’s in our post “Are Some Banks Cooking the Books?” Within its 114 pages, the BIS report painted a worrying picture of where the global economy stands. In fact, the risks in the global monetary system remain from the Lehman crisis in 2008 and aggregate debt ratios are almost 40 percentage points of GDP higher than a decade ago.
Crude oil prices were strongly up, their highest since November 2014 extending a rally for a fourth-straight week as focus shifted to the prospect of deeper losses of Iranian crude supplies as the U.S. threatened sanctions on countries that fail to halt Iranian crude imports by Nov. 4. Then there were unexpected disruptions in Canada, Libya and Venezuela, together curbing supply and in addition, U.S. crude supplies fell by 9.9 million barrels. Crude futures settled 65 cents higher on Friday as data showed U.S. oil rigs counts fell for the second straight week, pointing to signs of tightening domestic output.
The US dollar was roughly unchanged for the week as heavy selling pressure on Friday reversed earlier gain after the euro rallied sharply on news of EU members agreeing on measures to tackle the migrant crises in the EU including stepping up border security and setting up holding centers to handle asylum seekers. A signal of easing political uncertainty within the bloc sent the EUR/USD sharply higher, to $1.1677, up 0.94%. The US dollar fell 0.82% to 94.22 against a basket of major currencies on Friday.
Gold tumbled further again this week and suffered its biggest monthly slump since September as investors preferred the US$. This was partly because the FED indicated they were comfortable with inflation running above the inflation target over the near-term, in reaction to the news that inflation hit the Fed’s 2% target for the first time since May 2012, raising the prospect of a faster pace of rate hikes.
And the crypto crunch continues. Bitcoin for example went below $6,000 and it could go lower still. No one is sure where the firm base is, so expect more volatility ahead.
And talking of volatility the COBE VIX index ended the week at 16.09, having been higher earlier in the week, up from the 10-12 range seen earlier in the year, but well below the peaks seen in February. As an indicator of perceived risk, this suggests there are more in the system than last year.
Locally the Australian Dollar ended at 74 cents, and the trend down since February is striking, perhaps mirroring rising UD Bond rates, higher capital market interest rates, and the Financial Services Royal Commission which recommenced this week in Brisbane with a focus on country’s $50 billion farm sector and farm finance, 70% of which resides in Queensland, New South Wales and Victoria. And it was more really bad news for the banks, who again demonstrated poor practice, and in some cases deception. But this is a complex area, with farmers sensitive to weather extremes, global commodity prices, and changing land prices. And players such as liquidators seemed to profit from the failure of farmers, despite selling land and equipment well below value. They are not in scope for the Royal Commission, but we think they should be. There is clearly a case for ASIC to take a more hands-on role in farm finance as some rural lenders, such as the non-bank ones, are not covered by existing complaints-handling systems. But overall, this is another example of poor culture in the banking industry, and players including ANZ and CBA are under the microscope. The findings were so damming that the Commission decided to spend more time looking at farming case studies. For bank-originating farm debt, some lenders changed loan contract terms for farm businesses that were late with payments or in default without warning or explanation. More broadly, the Commission heard about declining access to banking services for the 6.9 million Australians in rural areas, the inflexibility of lenders toward farm-specific challenges like weather, trade disputes, and lack of customized regulations for the sector.
The latest credit data from APRA and RBA, out yesterday, showed that May credit slowed sharply to equal a 6-year low of 0.2% m/m, and a 4-year low of 4.8% y/y. We discussed this in our post “May Credit Snapshot Tells the Story”.
As UBS highlights, private credit growth has weakened more quickly than expected to only 0.2% m/m, the equal weakest since 2012; also dragging the y/y to an equal 4-year low of 4.8% (after 5.1%). Also, total deposits growth collapsed in recent months to only 2.4% y/y, the weakest since the last recession in 1991. Meanwhile, the household debt-to-income ratio lifted to a record high of 190% in Q1- 18. However, mainly due to falling house prices, household wealth declined by 0.4% q/q, the largest fall since 2011. While this followed a surge to a record high level of $10.3 trillion in Q4-17, the change in wealth drives the household saving ratio, consistent with a fading ‘household wealth effect’ dragging consumption ahead. They say this will spill over and an ~8-10% fall in new car sales volumes is a strong possibility, Further evidence of the second order impacts.
Housing auction clearance rates slid to a ~6-year low of ~54%, housing credit growth eased to a >4- year low dragged by investors slumping to a record low, while industry data on owner occupier home loans suggests this also started to drop in May; while home prices are falling the most since 2012. Macroprudential policy is reducing borrowing capacity and leading to a clear weakening of housing, which will continue ahead.
CoreLogic says last week, 1,849 auctions were held across the combined capital cities, returning a final clearance rate of 55.5 per cent, increasing from the previous week when 52.4 per cent of the 2,002 auctions held were successful, the lowest clearance rate seen since late 2012. This time last year, the clearance rate was 66.5 per cent across 2,355 auctions.
Melbourne’s final clearance rate was recorded at 59.9 compared with a clearance rate of 70.7 per last year. Sydney’s final auction clearance rate was 50.1 per cent compared with a clearance rate of 68.2 per cent last year. Across the smaller auction markets, clearance rates improved everywhere except Tasmania, however only 3 auctions were held there over the week. Of the non-capital city auction markets, Geelong returned the highest final clearance rate, with a success rate of 71.4 per cent across 26 auctions.
This week they expect to see a lower volume of auctions this week with CoreLogic currently tracking 1,557 auctions, down from 1,849 last week.
Home prices are falling with the CoreLogic 5-city daily dwelling price index, which covers the five major capital city markets, declined another 0.15%. So far in June home values have fallen 0.24%, driven by Melbourne, Sydney and Perth. So far in 2018, home values have declined by 1.72%, with only Brisbane and Adelaide recording a value increase. Over the past 12 months, home values have fallen by 1.72%, driven by Sydney and Perth. Despite the continuing falls. values are now up 36.2% since the 2010 peak at the 5-city level, driven overwhelmingly by exceptionally strong gains in Sydney at 60.2% followed by Melbourne 42.6% and Adelaide 9.8%. Brisbane is 8.3% and Perth is down 11.4% This is before inflation adjustments, which means in real terms only Sydney and Melbourne prices are ahead.
We see more banks lifting rates on the back of the higher BBSW and LIBOR rates. For example, effective Friday 3 July, ING in Australia said it was making changes to variable rates for existing owner occupier home loan customers. This means interest rates for existing residential home loan customers will increase by 0.10%.
Bank of Queensland announced the variable home loan rate for owner occupiers (principal and interest repayments) will increase by 0.09 per cent, per annum; variable home loan rate for owner occupiers (interest only repayments) will increase by 0.15 per cent, per annum; variable home loan rate for investors (principal and interest and interest only repayments) will increase by 0.15 per cent, per annum; and Owner occupier and investor Lines of Credit will increase by 0.10 per cent, per annum. Anthony Rose, Acting Group Executive, Retail Banking said today’s announcement is largely due to the increased cost of funding. “Funding costs have significantly risen since February this year and have primarily been driven by an increase in 30 and 90 day BBSW rates, along with elevated competition for term deposits.
This just extends the list of players lifting rates, and we think more will follow. So it was interesting to see Bendigo Bank chairman Robert Johanson saying that he believes the RBA has waited too long to move rates. “They’ve been trying to do too much work with monetary policy,” he told Banking Day. “I’m concerned that apart from the impact we’ve already seen on asset values, mortgage rates are going to break from the official cycle and will do so in a disruptive way.” The funding pressures on lenders are emerging at an awkward time for the Turnbull Government, which is required to call a federal election within the next 12 months. A series of out-of-cycle increases across the industry could induce a blistering political response from government politicians who are cognizant of the historical links between election outcomes and mortgage rate rises. Even small hikes would create significant pain as a piece on Nine News, using our mortgage stress data explained.
I discussed the current situation with Economist John Adams this week in an extended interview – see Australia’s Debt Bomb. I recommend this post as we go through the critical issues are how it may play out.
Finally, as we hit the end of the financial year, it’s worth reflecting on the highlights and lowlights of the past year. It has been a bit of a roller coaster, but those with shares invested direct, or via superfunds will have done well, again – as in 9 of the past 10 years has proved to be. We suspect the next 12 months will be less positive, as rising interest rates, trade wars and political tensions all mount. We also have an election ahead, which will also potentially create waves. Trade wars is the area to watch. Our dollar has been sliding through the year, and this is likely to continue next year as we struggle with GDP growth in this volatile environment.
Corporate profits have been growing fast, as companies cut costs and rationalise their businesses and this has translated to higher dividends – and about half have come from the financial services sector overall. Banks will be hard pressed to maintain their dividends ahead, as lending growth slows, pressure on their culture continues thanks to the Royal Commission and regulators exercising their muscles. And the greatest of these is mortgage lending growth which we think will continue to languish. Provisions, which were cut this year, may need to rise ahead as 90 days plus default rates are rising, as wages and cost pressure hit home. Remember also the next round of penalty rate reductions for 700,000 workers in across sectors such as retail will cut pay by 10% comes in 1 July.
Property has done less well, despite being well up over the past year, in that the recent monthly trends are signalling a fall. In some states we will end the year well up, for example Hobart, Adelaide and Melbourne, in others less well. We expect more falls ahead because prices are most strongly linked to credit supply, which is being throttled back. Most centres will be impacted as investors tread water and foreign buyer momentum slows. This might be good news for first time buyers who have been enticed back into the market, partly thanks to recent FTB incentives. We are bearish on the property sector next financial year.
Those needing to get income from savings and deposit accounts have had a torrid time, as banks have cut, and cut again their returns on savings. Many are getting less than inflation, so their hard earned cash has taken a hit. This is likely to continue, despite banks lifting mortgage rates as international funding pressure continues to bite in the months ahead. Households continue to be taxed on their savings at their marginal rate, while those with property get massive tax breaks. If Labor does win the next election, this is set for a shake up!
So overall a mixed year, with some highs and lows, and we think next year will be no different, only more so. Credit trajectory is the one to watch.
