Investment Property Loans ARE More Risky – Fitch

Fitch Ratings says that the investment loan reclassification process announced by National Australia Bank Limited will not result in a withdrawal or downgrade of Fitch’s ratings on the National RMBS Trust notes and outstanding issuance under NAB’s mortgage covered bond programme. The reclassification process has been initiated following a review of NAB’s housing loan purpose data which found misclassifications between ‘owner occupied’ and ‘investment’. The full list of ratings follows at the end of this commentary.

Fitch believes that investment-property loans will have a higher probability of default in an economic downturn, as borrowers will fight harder to protect their primary residence. The agency applies a 25% higher base default probability in the case of a mortgage collateralised by an investment property, compared with an owner-occupied property.

However, Fitch has tested the sensitivity of the ratings to an increase in the proportion of loans collateralised by investment properties. The analysis found that the RMBS notes’ and mortgage covered bond ratings are not impacted by an increase in expected foreclosure frequency following the increase of loans classified as investment loans in each of the rated transactions. The levels of credit enhancement (CE) available to each rated note issued under the National RMBS transactions would still be above Fitch’s adjusted break-even CE levels. The transactions are performing within expectations with low levels of arrears and losses.

The change of the proportion of investment loans in the cover pool would not impact Fitch’s ‘AAA’ break-even asset percentage (AP) of 89.5% on NAB’s mortgage covered bond programme. The ‘AAA’ break-even AP calculated by Fitch is mainly driven by the programme’s refinancing needs as a result of significant maturity mismatches and the agency’s refinancing assumptions.

NAB has stated that new procedures are being implemented and that identified gaps in data capturing have been rectified. This work forms part of an ongoing review to improve its statistical reporting process. Fitch has and will adjust its analysis assumptions on the National RMBS transactions and the NAB mortgage covered bond programme to reflect the ongoing work.

The affected RMBS transactions are securitisations of first-ranking Australian residential mortgages originated by Advantedge Financial Services Pty Limited and Challenger Mortgage Management Pty Limited: National 2011-1, National 2012-1 and National 2012-2; and National Australia Bank Limited: National 2011-2 and National 2015-1.

Author: Martin North

Martin North is the Principal of Digital Finance Analytics

Leave a Reply